I was planning on talking about "Justice League" #1 last week, but other priorities emerged, so I'll lump it in with the week one books. Which I am late on anyway.
The new "Justice League" book takes us back to the original formation of the team, five years ago. I love this concept, but I wonder how long it will last. DC surely can't have "Justice League" always five years behind, right? I'm guessing we get this one major "getting the team together" story arc, and then DC hits us with a big event that flash-forwards the book up to present day.
But whatever, I loved it. This first issue is almost entirely Batman and Green Lantern, a pairing that might be more impactful had the GL movie performed better at the box office (but still, dude's got an animated series coming up... and Batman hasn't been absent from the public eye for decades. Maybe ever.) It's a buddy action comedy, with these two guys running into each other for the first time and disliking each other's methods. Like a lot of Geoff Johns books, it's a screenplay with storyboards. And I love that.
I've seen a lot of detractors, but it seems to me that many of them wouldn't have been happy with the book no matter what was between the covers. People who hate DC, who hate Green Lantern, who hate Geoff Johns... they've all been standing in line to piss on this book before they read it. Several commenters take the book to task for not including the entire Justice League, with the rationale being that if DC expects to bring in new readers, DC ought to provide what's in the book's title.
This is bunk, and it underestimates the average person's appetite for serialized media. If a television network wants people to watch a new dramatic series, they don't spill the entire thing in the first episode. You meet main characters, you learn key basic relationships, and future episodes then reveal more people, more issues, more challenges. That's what's going on here - and has been going on in comics for some time - so to assume that these mythical "new readers" will be put off by the first issue of a "Let's Create a Justice League" story that does not finish the job is insulting to everyone's attention spans. How many Muppets did Kermit meet in the first twenty minutes of "The Muppet Movie"?
No, what keeps new readers away is the same thing that has always kept new readers away: the price and the delivery method. Too expensive, and too much time between installments. And the New 52 isn't doing much to address those concerns.
Anyway, let's move on to Week 1, in no particular order.
"Stormwatch" #1. Couple interesting DCnU tidbits in this issue. Seems like Stormwatch is the new Checkmate, the secret fringe organization of organized super-heroes that have quietly protected Earth for centuries. I like the team's assertion that these new super-heroes are amateurs while Stormwatch consists of "professional" heroes. Also, Martian Manhunter is pegged as having been in the Justice League... which is cool because, thus far, he has not been included in any of DC's official new League stuff. I don't like the lame Silver Surfer / Galactus riff for the bad guys here, because we've seen that a dozen times.
"Static Shock" #1. Static is a fun character, and his book has a Flash / young Spider-Man kind of vibe. He's a science nerd, with science powers, who has a science job. He has been relocated to New York City, which is interesting for a DC book, and the enemies in this issue seem to be the Power Rangers on hover bikes. This one does a good job of letting readers learn about Static; might feel less "baggage-y" for new readers than, say, Stormwatch.
"Hawk & Dove" #1. I've already tried out all of the following jokes on Josh, and they are all gold. I want to scan in every panel of this book and make fun of them. Rob Liefeld is a horrible artist. He has a child's understanding of anatomy and the sketching ability of a high school student who was just told by someone that he's good. I get that he was a kid twenty years ago when he sucked on X-Men books, but you'd think he would have improved somewhat since then. He's still fielding the same poses, the same faces, the same awful everything. Writer Sterling Gates probably has the characters smash up the Washington Monument in this issue because it's the only Washington DC landmark he could expect Liefeld to draw. An Asian character shows up halfway through, wearing sunglasses because Liefeld is incapable of drafting a recognizably Asian face. I should have somebody read this one to me, so I can see if it's possible to enjoy the script without the ghastly distraction of one of the worst artists in the industry.
"Batgirl" #1. The shocker here is how it deftly deals with "The Killing Joke," the famous story that put Barbara Gordon in a wheelchair for the next two decades of comics. She got better. Which makes sense, in comic book terms. Plenty of other characters have been crippled or mutated or outright killed... and got better. So why not her? She was still shot, she still spent time in a chair (was she still Oracle?) but now she's back in the uniform. Plus, an Asian character in this book appears in sunglasses and shortly lifts them up... which I would swear is a direct attack on Rob Liefeld if these books had not been published simultaneously.
"Green Arrow" #1. I like that Oliver Queen seems to be the super-heroic Steve Jobs of the DCnU. His company makes Q-Pods and Q-Phones, and this book makes them sound as ubiquitous as our Apple products. I like the modern take that Ollie works with trick tech arrows because he wants weapons that won't kill people (although he clearly has no problem with weapons that mangle people.)
"Men of War" #1. I was surprised that this "war" book still dabbles in super-heroes. The first story carries on the legacy of Sgt. Rock, and I guess is supposed to appeal to the Modern Warfare / Call of Duty crowd. The backup story was a little too "Full Metal Jacket" for me.
"Action Comics" #1. Easily the standout. Like "Justice League," this takes place in the past (maybe six years ago?) when Superman first appeared and the world first learned of the existence of super-heroes. This is what I like about both Action and JL: what if super-heroes debuted in the year 2005? Superman is young, almost drunk on his powers. I get the feeling that one of the things Grant Morrison is taking away from Superman is his perfection. One of the longstanding components of the character is that his Kansas upbringing ended up creating the perfectly moral figure who arrived in Metropolis one day to do good. Morrison is letting us see the character earn that morality, instead of just assuming Clark Kent has been awesomely pure since day one. I think he'll end up being the guidepost he has always been, and his Bible Belt America will be a part of that, but he's going to burn through some crazy post-teen years before he gets there. In this issue, Superman makes a big deal of working outside the law, because the law is not helping the common man. He's almost like Batman, except that he's a showman, he's public, he's making sure the police know what he's doing. Because, after all, nobody can do a damn thing to stop him. This is a motivated twenty something doing what he knows is right, with all the naive confidence that comes with being a motivated twenty something. It's a great read.
"Batwing" #1. Another really good one. I've said before that I like when we're allowed to see heroes from other countries, in other countries, instead of everything being so Americentric. I'm not entirely familiar with what went down in "Batman, Incorporated," but I get that Batman has deputized a Congo policeman to become a Bat-based hero in a part of the world that really needs heroic figures.
"O.M.A.C." #1. Better than expected. Keith Giffen's art is obviously in homage to Jack Kirby, and that's fun. It's nice to see Cadmus and Dubbilex and Brother Eye again, although O.M.A.C. himself is one unappealing-looking character.
"Animal Man" #1. Nice, creepy story. A lot of characters have had their families and marriages erased in the new DC, but Animal Man has kept his. The book even seems to reference his recent (dumb) adventures in space. The art is unsettling, which should be cool on a book that's going to be dark like this one, but lots of the panels look like traced photographs and that's never a good thing.
"Swamp Thing" #1. Also creepy, but with way better art. I'm still excited to see Swamp Thing back alongside the DC heroes.
"Detective Comics" #1. Great book. Sounds like this is the first time Batman catches the Joker, but naturally Joker lets him do it (if it's really him, which I'm not convinced it is.)
"Justice League International" #1. I'm walking in knowing I have a soft spot for this book. Not yet knowing what's going on in the present-day Justice League puts this book at a disadvantage, but I like the team, particularly August General in Iron. I'm not sure why Batman is involved, and I don't see why every Russian character in the book has to talk like a cheap cartoon stereotype... but it is funny how different this one is compared to "Justice League" #1. I wonder if the people who hated the decompressed, cinematic story in that book liked this one... the team is assembled, there's word balloons in every panel, there's in-fighting and action and setup. Almost the polar opposite of the terse Johns book.
So what will I stick with? I was down for both League books before they printed. Action is a must. I really liked Detective, but I'm afraid of stepping into the Bat-books for fear of having to get ALL the Bat-books. Even Batgirl, which already has a taste of what I liked about Gail Simone's "Secret Six." But I really want to see what happens next in Batwing. Also Swamp Thing and Animal Man. Those last three are characters I have never really followed (hell, Batwing is, what, not even a year old?), but these first issues did the job of making me curious. Stormwatch, Static Shock, Hawk & Dove, O.M.A.C, Men of War, Green Arrow? Not so much. I like some parts of Stormwatch and Green Arrow, but I don't think I can commit; I have to draw the lines somewhere.