[browse entry tags]

latest entries
>Oz books 5, 6 and 7
02.27.10 / Joe
>The Week in Links
02.27.10 / Joe
>Recent Blackest Night events, interpreted by Clark
02.25.10 / Joe
>How did I do? The Nintendo Power Awards 2009 recap
02.24.10 / Joe
>Didn't expect to play these games.
02.22.10 / Joe
>B&W Sunday Scan: Sam and Max - Pondering of the Ages
02.21.10 / Joe
>The Week in Links
02.19.10 / Joe
>I would buy the hell out of that.
02.18.10 / Joe
>A look ahead for 1Q and 2Q.
02.17.10 / Joe
>So I've been playing a lot of Wii lately...
02.16.10 / Joe

Here's what I'm thinking about the iPad.
Wednesday / 01.27.10 / 07:57PM / Joe / comments: 0

ipad-reveal.jpgThe name is lousy. But then again, what the hell's an "iPod?" How does "pod" pertain to music at all? I half suspect that, as more and more people filter over to buying iPhones (haven't vanilla flavor iPod sales been steadily declining ever since the Touch/iPhone appeared?), that Apple will dump the iPod entirely... thus creating a nice phonetic transition to iPad.

It's a shame that Today's Internet is coated in tacky menstruation jokes as a result. "Canvas" would have been a far cooler name, but one supposes Apple is married to the "i" bit now, for better or for worse.

The overall weirdness about today's presentation was that almost the entire thing was Steve Jobs and company talking about stuff that we would expect it to do anyway. Of course it will play your iTunes music/movies/shows. Of course it has apps. So it seemed like kind of a waste of time to keep belaboring that point. And, really, enough with the feints at the gamer market, Apple. You guys invited Kotaku for the press, that's it. After two years, we're only now barely starting to get iPhone games that you could actually call games... and even those pale in comparison to what you can get on your DS. iPhone games cost, on average, one fucking dollar and that's about what they're worth. Touchscreen Need for Speed? Whatever. Nothing will come of this until somebody figures out the kind of games that are made specifically for the device, not just sideways ports with touch-buttons pasted on to them.

I was waiting for the "one more thing" and it didn't happen. Boo.

The book store thing is okay, but stupidly expensive. $15 for a virtual book - a little more than most new paperbacks? How about $5 or less. Apple's media pricing has been inconsistent (I remember $10 iTunes albums being cheaper than actual CDs, but $2 TV shows and $15 movies are more expensive than buying DVDs), however this seems way off. Let's hope that Ted Kennedy book was a bad example. Essentially, we're paying more for the privilege of not needing shelf space... which any good book geek will tell you that having a glorious library room is part of the fun. I'm also a bit cheesed that paperbacks sell for $6 to $12 and factor in all the hard costs of creating it... while a $15 digital book has none of those costs, so why am I paying more?

I can't think of a more out-of-touch feature to harp on than the ability to read a newspaper. Seriously.

The more-or-less standard def aspect ratio is an odd choice. That letterboxed Star Trek sure looked like crap.

Immediate access to 99% of the iPhone App Store is a great start. This is like when Nintendo introduced the DS with a Game Boy Advance slot. It's also nice that you do not have to re-buy any iPhone apps for use on your iPad. They will just sync on over. Compare that to Microsoft's recent reveal that 360 owners who bought classic arcade games over XBLA will have to buy them again if they want them inside the upcoming Game Room feature.

The MLB.com thing could be huge. Did they mention what that would cost? I fully expect the MLB to sabotage the concept by charging $10/month for it. Still, watching live sports with the ability to pull down instant stats and replays? That's pretty slick.

I'd love to know if that painting program can take a stylus for precision art. I would love to be able to draw directly, as on the Wacom tablets of yore.

I like the idea of the $10 iWork apps. I'd certainly play around with the touch controls, even if I haven't needed any kind of Office anything since my junior year of college (that's a joke that references me not doing any work in my final year.) My old buddy Matt wants a touchable Final Cut app. I think this is another step on Apple's path of going touchscreen on all models, desktop/laptops included. Rather than doing it the Dell way, they're really checking this concept out and making sure people "get" it. The iPhone was step one.

Although getting these into business hands will be a tough sell, there are plenty of opportunities where a salesman with an iPad could stage some serious stuff. Easy slideshow creation, projector attachment, gesture controlling everything... that would be some impressive tech to whip out at a business meeting.

The lack of multitasking apps is a concern. I mean, it hasn't hurt the iPhone any, but with a larger screen people are going to assume they can have different program windows. On the iPhone, I can jump from Safari to Twitter with no problem, and the fact that one app "quits" is never really a problem. So I wouldn't call it a dealbreaker just yet. Part of the iPad's challenge is that people are going to constantly compare it to a "real" laptop and find reasons to call it lacking. I like how the iPhone OS lets everything just work. You don't need to worry with networking or directory paths or save locations. It's a smooth abstraction of the computing process, continuing the curve Apple started with the very first Macintosh. I'm perfectly OK with the iPad taking those lessons into a physically larger arena.

The model differentiation is confusing and a mistake. Did we really need three GB options? I think it's silly to break out the 3G version as being $130 more expensive. Sounds like another AT&T backroom argument. That $15/month 3G data cost is cheap, though, and makes me wonder if AT&T offered that up in return for something else... like more exclusivity months with the iPhone. DRAMATIC PRAIRIE DOG!

The Flash debate amuses. Apple is going to have trouble washing this one away. I get that Flash sort of sucks and is controlled by a diagonal competitor... but, again, with that big screen, people are going to be disappointed when they head to their favorite website and find a plugin error. On the iPhone there is a built-in acceptance because the device is small, and when was the last time a small browser was worth a damn, on your cell phone? I think not. But the iPad is going to confront the Flash issue head-on.

Where's the camera? I expect that to be item number one on the hardware revision list.

But that $500 price (for the low end model) is pretty amazing. Nobody predicted that (except me, about twenty minutes into the pitch). What's especially great about that is that it can only go down. Next year, the enhanced iPad 4G will be $300! (*speculation) At $500, consumers have a choice: spend half that and get a piece of shit Windows netbook, or spend double that and get a fullblown laptop.

I think there genuinely is a middle ground there, because we all know that most people just don't care about all the "potential" you get with a "real" computer. They simply never use it. Networking, upgrading, all that nerdy stuff. Most people don't even pull their SD cards out of their digital cameras, for crying out loud. And, as Apple pointed out, with 70 hojillion people out there who already know the iPad interface, it does seem like we've got a Trojan iPhone in our midst. Many people could be plainly happy with an iPad that is super-easy to install apps, brings in media, allows for web/email/IM, goes direct to Facebook and YouTube... and just happens to be a sexy piece of kit from a sexy company. Look at those posed models, those people are holding Sci-Fi datapads! The only way it could get more futuristic is if the damn thing floated in mid-air.

Just in our house, I know we use our iPhones all the time. The iPad is a bigger, meatier version that, potentially, doesn't cost as much a month.

But we all know better than to buy first-gen hardware, right? I'll be watching 2010 carefully. Rhonda and I technically do not own a current laptop, so a $500 finely honed version of what we saw today would be just the thing.

 

comments

fourhman.com allows registered commenting from Google, Yahoo, TypePad, VOX, OpenID, LiveJournal, WordPress and AIM.

    previous entry   next entry      
prev   A very appropriate rating
01.27.10
  Cheap games shootout 2009 - The Last Quintet
01.29.10
  next

This entry is tagged: iPad iPhone [browse all tags on fourhman.com]

weblog features
>AC Wild World Diary / 28 entries
>Animal Crossing in Pictures / 11 entries
>Animal Crossing Log / 31 entries
>Cheapo Game Shootout 07-08 / 11 entries
>Cheapo Game Shootout 2009 / 4 entries
>Farewell to the GameCube / 18 entries
>Farewell to the PS2 / 23 entries
>Gumby Book of Letters / 7 entries
>Our Trip to Korea / 7 entries
>Pokemon LeafNotes / 17 entries
>Pokemon Pearl Journal / 20 entries
>Pokemon Sapphire Diary / 23 entries
>Sam and Max Hit the Road / 30 entries
>Slashdot Comment History / 7 entries
>Smash Brawl Photos / 16 entries

weblog archive
>February 2010
>January 2010
>December 2009
>November 2009
>October 2009
>September 2009
>August 2009
>July 2009
>June 2009
>May 2009
>April 2009
>March 2009
>February 2009
>January 2009
>December 2008
>November 2008
>October 2008
>September 2008
>August 2008
>July 2008
>June 2008
>May 2008
>April 2008
>March 2008
>February 2008
>January 2008
>December 2007
>November 2007
>October 2007
>September 2007
>August 2007
>July 2007
>June 2007
>May 2007
>April 2007
>March 2007
>February 2007
>January 2007
>December 2006
>November 2006
>October 2006
>September 2006
>August 2006
>July 2006
>June 2006
>May 2006
>April 2006
>March 2006
>February 2006
>January 2006
>December 2005
>November 2005
>October 2005
>September 2005
>August 2005
>July 2005
>June 2005
>May 2005
>April 2005
>March 2005
>February 2005
>January 2005
>December 2004
>November 2004
>October 2004
>September 2004
>August 2004
>July 2004
>June 2004
>May 2004
>April 2004
>March 2004
>February 2004
>January 2004
>December 2003
>November 2003
>October 2003
>September 2003
>August 2003
>July 2003
>June 2003
>May 2003
>April 2003
>March 2003
>February 2003
>January 2003
>December 2002
>November 2002
>October 2002
>September 2002
>August 2002
>July 2002
>June 2002
>May 2002
>April 2002
>March 2002
>February 2002
>January 2002
>September 2001
>August 2001
>July 2001
>June 2001
>May 2001
>April 2001
>March 2001
>February 2001
>January 2001
>December 2000
>November 2000
>October 2000
>September 2000
>August 2000
>May 2000
>April 2000
>February 2000
>November 1999
>June 1999
>February 1999
>December 1998
>November 1998
>March 1998
>February 1998
 

[fourhman.com home] jump to top