I think this photo makes me look pretty tough. Tough enough to surround myself with people unimpressed by New Super Mario Bros Wii. Even while sitting on my t-shirt and wearing Paper Mario flannel pants.
On a related note, my buddy Mike lasted about thirty seconds with A Boy and His Blob before declaring the control scheme unmanageable. He has a way of cutting right to the bone, that one. He has also famously come out against Kingdom Hearts, Super Mario Galaxy and Killer 7. And he probably doesn't even remember being annoyed by that last one. My biggest claim to fame with Mike is that I got him to play Animal Crossing seriously for a couple months.
Let's get back to Nintendo Power's curious list of 2009 awards.
Take a peek at the Strategy Game noms. Has anybody ever heard of ANY of these games, outside of Little King's Story (which is really only famous for nobody playing it)? Is there a valid reason why we can't nominate New Play Control Pikmin?
Major boo to the Fire Emblem game screwing up the longstanding tradition of subtitling DS game with a D. S. abbreviation. Come on guys. You got so close.
Best Strategy Game: Fire Emblem: Shadow Dragon, Knights in the Nightmare, Little King's Story, Phantom Brave: We Meet Again, Valkyrie Profile: Covenant of the Plume
Voter pick: Little King's Story
Editor pick: Little King's Story
My pick: Little King's Story
The Best Shooter category will revert to a brand popularity contest, with The Conduit left out in the cold. I'll say that the public will go with Resident Evil, although House of the Dead will be close. I just don't think enough people that give a crap about Call of Duty give those craps on the Wii. NP will go with Dead Space and be insufferable about it.
Best Shooter: Call of Duty Modern Warfare Reflex, Conduit, Dead Space Extraction, House of the Dead: Overkill, Resident Evil: Darkside Chronicles
Voter pick: Resident Evil: Darkside Chronicles
Editor pick: Dead Space Extraction
My pick: House of the Dead: Overkill
Here's how you know sports games are dead on Wii, because that second dorky Sonic & Mario Olympics game is classified as one. Also Wii Sports Resort. I guess a category for Best Minigames Game would be too massive for NP to delineate.
I will not be far off in declaring a confused public waffling between Punch-Out (which is a very small game that people say is a very big one, just to sound like Old Nintendo Pros) and Wii Sports Resort, which is about half garbage.
Best Sports Game: Madden NFL 10, Mario Sonic Olympic Bullshit 2: White Version, NHL 2K10, Punch-Out, Tiger Woods 10, Wii Sports Resort
Voter pick: Punch-Out
Editor pick: Punch-Out
My pick: Wii Sports Resort
Let's pause to note that there is no Best Driving Game category. No love for Excitebots. They might as well have pitched that one into Best Sports.
I said previously that I like NP's distinction between Adventure and Action, and now you can see why. All the "Action" games are superfast. And, with the notable exception of Sonic and the Black Knight, they're all actually good games. I have trouble imagining the voters going with Madworld (I'm going to deny a fanboy love affair with Sonic on this one), but it's probably the most-played game on the list.
Best Action Game: Contra ReBirth, Gradius ReBirth, Madworld, Muramasa, Sonic and the Black Knight
Voter pick: Madworld
Editor pick: Muramasa: The Demon Blade
My pick: Madworld
Has there ever been a Best Platformer year that a Mario game didn't win? Didn't crush? New Super Mario Bros Wii will demolish this category. It really doesn't have any competition.
Best Platformer: Boy and His Blob, Henry Hatsworth, Klonoa, Lost Winds 2, NSMBW, NyxQuest
Voter pick: New Super Mario Bros Wii
Editor pick: New Super Mario Bros Wii
My pick: Klonoa
The Best Puzzle list shows off a diversity of puzzle concepts... because I probably would not lump Boom Blox, Scribblenauts, Peggle and Layton in one bucket. Interesting faceoff here. Scribblenauts will sweep, although Layton and Might & Magic will have a strong following. Naturally, I must point out that Scribblenauts does not deserve it, but maybe this sort of adulation will get us a Scribblenauts 2 that does.
Nice job Peggle for keeping up the DS subtitle convention, even if it sounds dirty.
Best Puzzle Game: Art Style Precipice, Boom Blox Bash Party, Might & Magic: Clash of Heroes, Peggle: Dual Shot, Layton 2, Scribblenauts
Voter pick: Scribblenauts
Editor pick: Scribblenauts
My pick: Professor Layton and the Diabolical Box
Best New Character is offered as proof that new IP does indeed come to Nintendo systems. As usual, it's a weird mish-mash of titles. Henry Hatsworth has no chance. Jack of Madworld is a probable. Lexine of Dead Space Extraction has no chance. Little King has no chance. Morgan LeFlay of Tales of Monkey Island is an iffy maybe. Xion of Kingdom Hearts DS has a tiny shot. Weird category. Funny that Maxwell from Scribblenauts did not make the cut.
I'm torn, because Henry Hatsworth has really funny voicework, and the backstory is better than you'd expect. Jack sounds like Spike from Cowboy Bebop, though, and that makes him supercool.
Best New Character: Hatsworth, Jack, Lexine, Little King, Morgan, Xion
Voter pick: Jack (Madworld)
Editor pick: Morgan LeFlay (Tales of Monkey Island)
My pick: Jack (Madworld)
Best Multiplayer is offered as proof that multiplayer does indeed come to Nintendo systems. Again, we can expect another award for New Super Mario Bros Wii, even if the multiplayer amounts to everyone I know simultaneously dying over and over again. That game is meant for pros, even though Nintendo spent a million dollars telling us it was made for everybody... which meant the pros spent months whining about how the Super Guide would ruin the game, and then it turns out the Super Guide pretty much sucks and is really hard to invoke anyway. Pros, go enjoy that game. It's exactly what you wanted.
Christ, I'm surprised they didn't nominate Yellow Toad for Best New Character.
Another mention of the Conduit here, which is getting hilarious.
Best Multiplayer: Call of Duty Reflex, Conduit, Guitar Hero 5, NSMBW, Phantasy Stay 0, Wii Sports Resort
Voter pick: New Super Mario Bros Wii
Editor pick: New Super Mario Bros Wii
My pick: Wii Sports Resort
Finally, we have Best Story/Writing. Another neat mashup of titles, but I think we can safely slot this as a notch for Bowser's Inside Story. You might see some activity from the Kingdom Hearts and Silent Hill contingents, but I doubt they can unseat one of the best DS games of the year.
Best Story/Writing: Dead Space Extraction, Dragon Quest V, House of the Dead, Kingdom Hearts DS, Mario & Luigi, Silent Hill: Shattered Memories
Voter pick: Mario & Luigi: Bowser's Inside Story
Editor pick: Mario & Luigi: Bowser's Inside Story
My pick: Mario & Luigi: Bowser's Inside Story
On both public and editorial votes, I foresee easy four wins for New Super Mario Bros Wii (taking every category in which it is nominated). Spirit Tracks will get four voter wins, but will not see as much action from the NP editors thanks to several other important DS games wrangling the niche categories. The winners will be announced in the March issue.