[browse entry tags]

latest entries
>WTF VGXPO?
12.02.08 / Joe
>What to do with Uncharted after blowing through it in under four days.
12.02.08 / Joe
>Things We Learned This Week
12.01.08 / Joe
>The Week in Links
11.29.08 / Joe
>A toilet, a fan and a jackhammer.
11.28.08 / Joe
>VGXPO, worth at least $15
11.26.08 / Joe
>Aeropodcast #59 and sort-of-lame video game cons.
11.25.08 / Joe
>Things We Learned This Week
11.23.08 / Joe
>The Week in Links
11.22.08 / Joe
>Presenting Animal Crossing in Pictures
11.20.08 / Joe

You know what? Screw Narnia.
Tuesday / 12.13.05 / 01:40PM / Joe

I was never into the Narnia series. By the time I discovered it, I was already old enough to realize when I was being pandered to, and anything that held the theme of "small children escape from the adult world and accomplish great and amazing things" was very easily dismissed. I was the kind of kid that thought Jungle Book would have been a much better movie without Mowgli in it.

If I had been of age when Batman introduced "the sensational character find of 1940," Robin, I would have felt the same way. Oh, so because I'm a kid I'm supposed to care more about Batman because now he has a kid like me hanging around? Wonderful. I didn't like Robin until DC grew him up and took him away from Batman.

So I'm not interested at all in the new movie, and even less so now that the fundies have latched onto it as a propaganda tool. While it is true that C.S. Lewis specifically wrote the Narnia series as a Christian allegory, it is also true that he masked it well. Most kids reading those books don't make the connection at all, unless they are told to, and that it stands as just another low-end fantasy story. I've read a ton of low-end fantasy stories and I can say that most of them contain the same kind of themes that Lewis included in Narnia, but were not intended as hardcore religious peaching and were not co-opted by latter day conversionists trying to present them as such. It's just good storytelling: heroic figure sacrifices self for others. You can find that simple message in millions of stories, and only a fraction of those would have any religious connection. I think Goose from Top Gun is a Christ figure.

It is disgusting how Disney has actively persued the "Christian market" to promote the film, as they seek to duplicate Mel Gibson's Passion success. Not that I would expect anything altruistic from a major American corporation like Disney, just that the company hasn't been doing that well in recent years and they quite plainly backed a project with the style of Lord of the Rings but the potential bank account of Passion. That's what is sad. Disney hand-picked an entire religion to act as their safety net should the movie not perform. They won't do as well as Mel, simply because Narnia is too fantastical and that the most fundy of the fundies will still take umbrage to Lewis's childlike concept of "Christ does D&D." You can't get those people into a movie theater under any circumstances and Disney knows that.

No, Narnia is targeted towards the casual Christian, particularly the bubble-family who considers themselves to be out there against the wilds of temptation with naught but VeggieTales DVDs to safely entertain them. Like Lord of the Rings, Narnia has that visceral CG action but also can promise a good message. It's the blockbuster movie experience the kids want, wrapped around what parents can be assured is a nugget of wholesome Jesus teachings. You just have to walk into the theater accepting that Christ is a lion. Finally, a movie that makes it obvious enough! Although I'm sure Disney's church-specific press releases helped.

Which, of course, is ridiculous. If the books can hide the metaphor, the movies will do it doubly so. Or at least the movie will come off as no more overtly religious than Star Wars, LOTR, the Matrix or Harry Potter. It's there if you're looking for it - and definitely there if you're actively creating a discussion of it - but you could still see a good movie for a good movie without it. It's that hypocrisy that grinds me... the idea that somehow this stupid fantasy CG movie is better for kids/families/humanity than any other stupid fantasy CG movie. Most US movies are made by Christians, and lots of movies contain elements that could be inspired by the Christ story. Only because C.S. Lewis wrote a couple of rambling, blatant "I'm a humble Christian" books does this movie get the big seal of approval. If J.K. Rowling does the same thing in her golden years, we'll get a whole new reading of the Potter books, believe it.

By the way, Narnia's opening weekend take - $65 million - is just under the opening weekend take of another highly successful, critically lauded and universally praised feature film: Rush Hour 2.

 

comments

fourhman.com allows registered commenting from TypeKey, VOX, OpenID, LiveJournal and AIM.

    previous entry   next entry      
prev   Clark is NOT helping.
12.13.05
  Best 350 bells I ever spent.
12.14.05
  next

This entry is tagged: Books Movies Rant Religion [browse all tags on fourhman.com]

weblog features
>AC Wild World Diary / 28 entries
>Animal Crossing in Pictures / 2 entries
>Animal Crossing Log / 31 entries
>Cheapo Game Shootout 07-08 / 9 entries
>Farewell to the GameCube / 18 entries
>Farewell to the PS2 / 23 entries
>Gumby Book of Letters / 7 entries
>Our Trip to Korea / 7 entries
>Pokemon LeafNotes / 17 entries
>Pokemon Pearl Journal / 20 entries
>Pokemon Sapphire Diary / 23 entries
>Sam and Max Hit the Road / 30 entries
>Slashdot Comment History / 7 entries
>Smash Brawl Photos / 16 entries

weblog archive
>December 2008
>November 2008
>October 2008
>September 2008
>August 2008
>July 2008
>June 2008
>May 2008
>April 2008
>March 2008
>February 2008
>January 2008
>December 2007
>November 2007
>October 2007
>September 2007
>August 2007
>July 2007
>June 2007
>May 2007
>April 2007
>March 2007
>February 2007
>January 2007
>December 2006
>November 2006
>October 2006
>September 2006
>August 2006
>July 2006
>June 2006
>May 2006
>April 2006
>March 2006
>February 2006
>January 2006
>December 2005
>November 2005
>October 2005
>September 2005
>August 2005
>July 2005
>June 2005
>May 2005
>April 2005
>March 2005
>February 2005
>January 2005
>December 2004
>November 2004
>October 2004
>September 2004
>August 2004
>July 2004
>June 2004
>May 2004
>April 2004
>March 2004
>February 2004
>January 2004
>December 2003
>November 2003
>October 2003
>September 2003
>August 2003
>July 2003
>June 2003
>May 2003
>April 2003
>March 2003
>February 2003
>January 2003
>December 2002
>November 2002
>October 2002
>September 2002
>August 2002
>July 2002
>June 2002
>May 2002
>April 2002
>March 2002
>February 2002
>January 2002
>September 2001
>August 2001
>July 2001
>June 2001
>May 2001
>April 2001
>March 2001
>February 2001
>January 2001
>December 2000
>November 2000
>October 2000
>September 2000
>August 2000
>May 2000
>April 2000
>February 2000
>November 1999
>June 1999
>February 1999
>December 1998
>November 1998
>March 1998
>February 1998
 
Play-Asia.com - Buy Video Games for Consoles and PC - From Japan, Korea and other Regions!

[fourhman.com home] jump to top