[browse entry tags]

latest entries
>Things We Learned This Week
11.16.08 / Joe
>$44 on comics
11.15.08 / Joe
>The Week in Links
11.14.08 / Joe
>There is no justice in tabletop gaming.
11.11.08 / Joe
>Aeropodcast #57 and Mirror's Edge
11.11.08 / Joe
>Things We Learned This Week
11.09.08 / Joe
>The Week in Links
11.07.08 / Joe
>No, Speed Racer, No!
11.06.08 / Joe
>Mega woot.
11.05.08 / Joe
>Halloween 2008
11.03.08 / Joe

The Two Towers
Tuesday / 12.24.02 / 12:08AM / Joe

OK, you've had a weekend to see The Two Towers. Time to talk about it now.

This one strays a bit more from the books. When Fellowship differed from the books, it was generally because Peter Jackson had to leave stuff out. In Two Towers, he seems to be putting stuff in. By and large, it's perfectly okay, because the added bits resonate with other scenes... in short, the tweaks make sense, from a movie perspective.

Elves at Helm's Deep. There's several reasons for this anomaly. It adds a little physical weight against the long-standing Tolkien complaint that all these powerful elves never do anything over the course of the story. The Professor can explain it over many chapters; all PJ can do is some rushed scenes with elves talking about Valinor. In the movie's vision, the elves battalion also helps bolster Theoden's defense... PJ's version of the defense of Helm's Deep is more hopeless than Tolkien's, in my opinion. The women and children stuck in the Glittering Caves, the six hours notice of the impending attack... and no huorns to bail everybody out at the end. But I think the most important reason is the return of Haldir. If PJ was doing a straight translation of the book, we'd have tons and tons of characters that are introduced, do something fairly important, and then never seen again. Haldir is a recognizable character from Fellowship, part of the movie's supporting cast... and he returns in Two Towers to die. It's actually kind of nice to see somebody important die. Nothing truly terrible ever happens to our leads - which is why Aragorn was tossed over a cliff - so B-teamers like Haldir (and Hama) have to step up.

Faramir. I have to admit I was a little bothered by this darker Faramir, but then I read this article from The One Ring.net which puts it into perspective. The movie version doesn't seem so off now. In the book, he just had more stage time to develop his interrogation and come to his decision. And "A chance for Faramir, Captain of Gondor, to show his quality" is one of my favorite lines. The battle scenes in Osgiliath are added just so all three storylines can culminate in war.

The truncated Entmoot. Much too hasty. I thought this was one of the weaker drifts, simply because it's purpose is to reveal an overwrought environmentalist moment. Treebeard really should have been aware of the deforestation of Isengard, and not be tricked by Merry and Pippen into discovering it. Still, I'd rather have a slightly dopey Treebeard than no Treebeard at all. The payoff for the altered Ent scenes is the inclusion of the amazing attack on Isengard, a portion that Tolkien totally glosses over. Maybe Return of the King will begin with Gandalf and company riding to Isengard and finding Merry and Pippen at their ease among the ruin.

 

comments

fourhman.com allows registered commenting from TypeKey, VOX, OpenID, LiveJournal and AIM.

    previous entry   next entry      
prev   Substance
12.18.02
  This will suck.
12.24.02
  next

This entry is tagged: Lord of the Rings Movies Spoiler [browse all tags on fourhman.com]

weblog features
>AC Wild World Diary / 28 entries
>Animal Crossing Log / 31 entries
>Cheapo Game Shootout 07-08 / 9 entries
>Farewell to the GameCube / 18 entries
>Farewell to the PS2 / 23 entries
>Gumby Book of Letters / 7 entries
>Our Trip to Korea / 7 entries
>Pokemon LeafNotes / 17 entries
>Pokemon Pearl Journal / 20 entries
>Pokemon Sapphire Diary / 23 entries
>Sam and Max Hit the Road / 30 entries
>Slashdot Comment History / 7 entries
>Smash Brawl Photos / 16 entries

weblog archive
>November 2008
>October 2008
>September 2008
>August 2008
>July 2008
>June 2008
>May 2008
>April 2008
>March 2008
>February 2008
>January 2008
>December 2007
>November 2007
>October 2007
>September 2007
>August 2007
>July 2007
>June 2007
>May 2007
>April 2007
>March 2007
>February 2007
>January 2007
>December 2006
>November 2006
>October 2006
>September 2006
>August 2006
>July 2006
>June 2006
>May 2006
>April 2006
>March 2006
>February 2006
>January 2006
>December 2005
>November 2005
>October 2005
>September 2005
>August 2005
>July 2005
>June 2005
>May 2005
>April 2005
>March 2005
>February 2005
>January 2005
>December 2004
>November 2004
>October 2004
>September 2004
>August 2004
>July 2004
>June 2004
>May 2004
>April 2004
>March 2004
>February 2004
>January 2004
>December 2003
>November 2003
>October 2003
>September 2003
>August 2003
>July 2003
>June 2003
>May 2003
>April 2003
>March 2003
>February 2003
>January 2003
>December 2002
>November 2002
>October 2002
>September 2002
>August 2002
>July 2002
>June 2002
>May 2002
>April 2002
>March 2002
>February 2002
>January 2002
>September 2001
>August 2001
>July 2001
>June 2001
>May 2001
>April 2001
>March 2001
>February 2001
>January 2001
>December 2000
>November 2000
>October 2000
>September 2000
>August 2000
>May 2000
>April 2000
>February 2000
>November 1999
>June 1999
>February 1999
>December 1998
>November 1998
>March 1998
>February 1998
 
Play-Asia.com - Buy Video Games for Consoles and PC - From Japan, Korea and other Regions!

[fourhman.com home] jump to top